STREET WEEK SNAFU IN TEXAS
LOGOS bookstore in Dallas, Tx has begun selling WHITE FLAG, one week early and all you-know-what will now break lose.
Maybe.
Let me explain why.
First of all, I'm not angry with LOGOS unless they sold the CD early on purpose to get a jump on competition. That's not fair. But I doubt that's what happened. Sometimes stores, even huge chains, make mistakes, read a release date incorrectly, get confused, and put a disc on shelves before it's time. Mistakes happen to us all. Easily forgiven.
But this is a bad thing, regardless of why it happened, for a few reasons - none of which are all that life and death for sure.
Street Week (the week a CD released officially) is a major opportunity for momentum to be built with retailer, media, touring and radio. In Dallas, for instance, where my single Bless the Lord is not being played, it would be helpful perhaps to be able to report to the local station that WHITE FLAG was in the top 5 best selling CDs in the city on street week. They might consider the single just based on the size of my audience in their station's range. They should anyway. Or if a retailer down the street isn't carrying my CD they might stock up if our sales on street week were greater than they expected. And total nationwide sales often make great press releases that excite potential promoters and media and create buzz that generates shows, sales, coverage and, hopefully, more chances to infect brains with the messages in the music. That's the hope anyway.
But selling a week early means those sales at LOGOs will not count as street week sales. And they'll be missed since they supposedly sold tons by setting up shop at a massive Christian festival in Dallas hosted by the largest station in town. That's a lot of sales that will never be tallied.
But that's not all. What about the person who pre-ordered WHITE FLAG weeks ago? 600+ pre-orders have been taken just at my shows in the last month or so. These pre-ordered because it was only $5 to do so at a show and $9 on-line and because they thought they'd be some of the first people to get the CD - on July 12.
And what about LOGOS' competition? If I owned a store in Dallas that was playing by the rules and released when asked to on July 12th I'd be a little upset with LOGOS right now. id' be really upset if the record they jumped the gun on turned out to be a charting record - in the top ten even. I'd wonder how many more sales I would have had if people had to choose between my store and LOGOS on July 12th. I'd also wonder about LOGO's motivations for thwarting the street date restrictions - are clueless or greedy? I'd wonder.
The businessman side of me would wonder - fairly or not. And the business side of me today isn't real pleased that this happened but the preacher side of me, the nice guy side of me, doesn't really mind. Most of me really doesn't care how somebody gets my music or when, as long as it's legal, as long as the words and meaning on that round chunk of silicon go beyond the ears to the heart and mind of the listener. That's what really matters. So really all that's happened is some people in one city got to smile, cry, be challenged or encouraged (or disappointed and confused) seven days before everyone else. Not the end of the world.
So if you work for my label please give LOGOS a break. If you own a store in their area don't beat them up too badly. But if you live in Dallas and happen to pay LOGOS a visit anytime soon, do me a favor, bring them a calendar so this doesn't happen again.
Got thoughts? Discuss this SHLOG on my message-board
Maybe.
Let me explain why.
First of all, I'm not angry with LOGOS unless they sold the CD early on purpose to get a jump on competition. That's not fair. But I doubt that's what happened. Sometimes stores, even huge chains, make mistakes, read a release date incorrectly, get confused, and put a disc on shelves before it's time. Mistakes happen to us all. Easily forgiven.
But this is a bad thing, regardless of why it happened, for a few reasons - none of which are all that life and death for sure.
Street Week (the week a CD released officially) is a major opportunity for momentum to be built with retailer, media, touring and radio. In Dallas, for instance, where my single Bless the Lord is not being played, it would be helpful perhaps to be able to report to the local station that WHITE FLAG was in the top 5 best selling CDs in the city on street week. They might consider the single just based on the size of my audience in their station's range. They should anyway. Or if a retailer down the street isn't carrying my CD they might stock up if our sales on street week were greater than they expected. And total nationwide sales often make great press releases that excite potential promoters and media and create buzz that generates shows, sales, coverage and, hopefully, more chances to infect brains with the messages in the music. That's the hope anyway.
But selling a week early means those sales at LOGOs will not count as street week sales. And they'll be missed since they supposedly sold tons by setting up shop at a massive Christian festival in Dallas hosted by the largest station in town. That's a lot of sales that will never be tallied.
But that's not all. What about the person who pre-ordered WHITE FLAG weeks ago? 600+ pre-orders have been taken just at my shows in the last month or so. These pre-ordered because it was only $5 to do so at a show and $9 on-line and because they thought they'd be some of the first people to get the CD - on July 12.
And what about LOGOS' competition? If I owned a store in Dallas that was playing by the rules and released when asked to on July 12th I'd be a little upset with LOGOS right now. id' be really upset if the record they jumped the gun on turned out to be a charting record - in the top ten even. I'd wonder how many more sales I would have had if people had to choose between my store and LOGOS on July 12th. I'd also wonder about LOGO's motivations for thwarting the street date restrictions - are clueless or greedy? I'd wonder.
The businessman side of me would wonder - fairly or not. And the business side of me today isn't real pleased that this happened but the preacher side of me, the nice guy side of me, doesn't really mind. Most of me really doesn't care how somebody gets my music or when, as long as it's legal, as long as the words and meaning on that round chunk of silicon go beyond the ears to the heart and mind of the listener. That's what really matters. So really all that's happened is some people in one city got to smile, cry, be challenged or encouraged (or disappointed and confused) seven days before everyone else. Not the end of the world.
So if you work for my label please give LOGOS a break. If you own a store in their area don't beat them up too badly. But if you live in Dallas and happen to pay LOGOS a visit anytime soon, do me a favor, bring them a calendar so this doesn't happen again.
Got thoughts? Discuss this SHLOG on my message-board
6 Comments:
D'ya suppose you could take a post and explain why/how labels set street dates? My gut says it's so that labels have time to rev up the marketing machine, but I would really like to think there are other reasons (like pressing discs and distro). I would also be interested to know how much time passes between when an album finishes production and when it hits the street.
As an interested observer, I appreciate the stuff that you share about the music industry.
oh dear!
snafu is right. . yikes!
I'm still patiently waiting to buy the CD. . esp. since i haven't heard your music and my local store seems to be all out of your other stuff, so i can't even buy something older! d'oh!
This practice of ignoring street dates bothers me. When it comes to music and books we have two types of stores in our town - the ones that put them out too early and the ones who put them out weeks after the street date. In fact, the late ones usually don't know what I'm talking about weeks after the book or CD released. So I don't want to help those who break the rules make a profit, but I can't get the product on the release day unless I do! So what's a girl to do? I drive to another town about 40 minutes away on release day which isn't really cost-effective with the price of gas these days. Why can't we all just follow the rules and start selling on the STREET DAY? It would make my life so much easier AND I could spend all that money I waste on gas buying more CD's and books!
Or you could shop on-line.
shoppin' on line would solve the gas expense problem!
wow. . i'm so unaware of so much. i think i like it that way? you know what they say about ignorance. . .
Well, I shop online for anything but new books or music. There's just something about buying it at the store. The anticipation for months of knowing a CD you've been dying to hear is coming soon builds to that one moment of perfect joy when you wake up and know that today's the day.
Then you drive to the store, often playing past releases by whomever's CD you are heading out to purchase. Then there's the whole process of finding the item - is it on the shelves, in a display, or the end of an aisle...where could it be? This is followed by the thrill when you find it and snatch your copy from the shelves - what bliss.
Then you walk to the checkout counter and wait for the debit machine to approve your pin number which is closely followed by ripping the plastic off the package on your walk to the car. (Usually in my world, this is followed by a ten minute rant on why CD manufacturing is done by people who obviously believe state secrets are hidden inside for what other reason would there be to make the darn things so hard to get into!)
The last step is driving home with my new tunes which often means sitting in the driveway with the motor running for an hour because I can't bring myself to pull the cd out and stop listening long enough to get in the house.
So that's why internet purchasing, though efficient, is clearly a lesser form of shopping in my humble opinion. Wow...this post makes me sound kinda sad. I promise I really do have a life.
Post a Comment
<< Home